So no reason to beat around the bush. I walked back in and bought a freaking red 1200S touring edition

Damn I am so happy with this bike. For me it feels like the right choice. I don't have any trouble staying in urban mode and riding carefully. For the record, I'm 30 and have seen enough accidents to know that the street isn't a place to screw around (too much anyway).
Random thoughts about the experience:
I was surprised how much narrower and lower the Triumph 800XC seat feels in comparison. I could flat foot that bike (I have about a 32" inseam) whereas on the 1200S I needed the lower seat.
The riding position on monsters is more aggressive than I expected from looking at the bike.
The 1200S turns in easier than the Suzuki S40 did, which is a pleasant surprise. Oddly enough, it also feels more stable in the wind.
The fog was rolling in by the time I left, so I haven't had a chance to go on a longer ride. I can't wait for tomorrow after work
